Lilly and Cummins a day late; Hoosiers a dollar short

by | Aug 11, 2022 | Politics/Government, Pop/Life

photo from

On Friday night, while the Indiana General Assembly was turning back the clock on human rights, I was at the Egyptian Room of the Old National Center to see a comedy show. With all of the tragically unfunny things going on for the last few weeks under the dome a few blocks away, the timing of the Marc Maron tickets I bought months earlier were a welcome reprieve. 

Right around the time the show was ending, the legislature was passing Indiana’s new abortion ban. Shortly after I got home, Gov. Eric Holcomb was signing it into law. Early the next day, Eli Lilly and Company issued a statement informing the state of its negative view of it. 

There’s still nothing funny about this, so let’s get back to comedy. 

Maron’s act has become known for a self-deprecating approach that is now filled with references to the harsh reality of being a 58-year-old man. I’m almost his age, so his humor makes near-perfect sense to me. 

However, what turned out to be more striking was the opening act, a woman named Laura Beitz (pronounced “Bites”). She lives in Los Angeles but was born and raised in Milwaukee. I expected to hear a little Hoosier bashing because of what was happening across town. Nope. There was none of that. Quite the contrary.

She noted how friendly the people are here and gave a couple of examples. “The guy behind me in line at CVS is going to a wedding in Canada. I didn’t ask him.” When I got done laughing at that—I realized it’s funny because it’s such an accurate sampling of us. Haha, right?

Then she told a story that wasn’t about Hoosiers at all. Not really. Though it definitely made me think.

Beitz painted a fascinating picture of her boyfriend, one vivid enough to make anyone listening wonder why they were together at all. But the two of them are trying to make it work. She said, “I am going to couples counseling, which is where I pay a man to repeat exactly what I’ve been saying, in a man’s voice, so my boyfriend can hear it…and it’s worth every penny.”

Whether Midwesterners are friendly or not, like the comedian’s boyfriend, swaths of us are having trouble hearing, learning and understanding. I don’t know if simply changing the messenger would have much of an impact, but I do know that the first step toward a solution is the acknowledgement that there is a problem. 

So, the day after Indiana added to its growing list of problems through passage of Senate Enrolled Act 1, one of its largest employers spoke up. In a statement issued on Saturday morning, Lilly claimed the new law could “hinder its ability to attract diverse scientific engineering and business talent from around the world,” and that, “we will be forced to plan for more employment growth outside our home state.”

Cummins too

It was a statement viewed by many as a day late. 

The company was skewered on social media platforms for showing up just after the all-invited debate ended. Justifiably so. On the other hand, who didn’t already know this? Later in the weekend, it turned out Cummins knew it too. 

In a CNBC article on Sunday, the Columbus, Indiana-based engine manufacturer gave its tardy input. “There are provisions in the law…that impact our people, impede our ability to attract and retain top talent and influence our decisions as we continue to grow our footprint with a focus on selecting welcoming and inclusive environments,” a company spokesman said.

Though these statements may be late, they are unquestionably true and were known to be true long ago. No one valuable is coming to Indiana, investing in Indiana, or staying in Indiana because of the new law. Did we learn nothing from the Religious Freedom Restoration Act? 

Indiana’s abortion law makes Indiana a less desirable place. The state has become an un-showered, unshaven, repulsive looking man wondering why it can’t find a date on Saturday nights. More accurately, the state is becoming more isolated on Monday mornings, when the “State that Works” once started its week. 

It’s difficult for me to be angry at business leaders on this one. As Niki Kelly wrote last week, even Holcomb was nearly as absent. 

Like Beitz’s couples’ counselor, we need to speak to the legislature in a voice they can hear. It will come best in the form of a vote.


  1. Morton Marcus

    One again the nail has been hit most effectively. Thanks. Perhaps we should have billboards showing you as The Hammer.

    I suspect, without evidence, Lilly and Cummins knew their opinions would not matter before the vote. They may remember RFRA and how it was passed and rescinded. By coming in after the vote, they can be seen as leading the opposition. I don’t say that cynically.

  2. Robert Knoop

    I don’t base my decisions or beliefs on what Lilly or Cummins deem right. They both have skeletons in their closets. If people are not happy with the law get involved with changing it via proper channels. Plenty of good people and companies are coming to Indiana.


Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Share This